Coherence as the process of joint and integrated policy making. Lessons learned from a cross-project collaboration to analyze the implementation of global agendas in Germany.

Publication of a case study at the interface of Sustainable Development, Adaptation to Climate Change and Disaster Risk Management

In 2015, the global community adopted the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the Paris Agreement and the Sendai Framework on Disaster Risk Reduction, all of which have substantial areas of overlap and clear convergence of objectives related to strengthening resil­ience, fostering sustainable development, and reducing vulnerability to climate change and disasters.

The Sendai Framework and a number of the individual Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the 2030 Agenda mention resilience as the central aspect. Similarly, the Paris Agreement acknowledges the links between climate action and sustainable devel­opment while the 2030 Agenda highlights the role of adverse climate change impacts in undermining sus­tainable development. At the same time, the Sendai Framework recognizes climate change as a driver of disaster risk and that dis­aster risk reduction (DRR) is essential for sustainable development. Therefore, build­ing strategic linkages and coordinating actions of the three fields could increase the effectiveness of differ­ent actions and related goals and should be promoted.

While many governments recognize the value of coherence, they struggle to understand what closer horizontal and vertical integration and coherent policy processes look like in practice and how they can be achieved. Further, research on good examples of coherent policy processes under the different agendas is limited and it does not provide any practical recommendations and lessons learned on the necessary enabling factors and mechanisms that would help create functional linkages for a coherent approach toward the systematic implementation of the global agendas.

To contribute to filling this gap and to support the international community, a cross-project team within the GIZ has set out to explore emerging good practices and practical learnings on fostering coherence. The authors also analyzed the mechanisms and enabling factors that contribute to the development of a coherent approach across different levels of governance in Germany. This case study captures lessons learned and translates them into good practices, which can be applied by decisionmakers in developed and developing countries as well as emerging economies.

The case study showcases how the coherent implementation of the agendas in Germany is based upon a strong political will and underscores the fact that coherence involves considering all administrative levels. Although it has been discovered, that there is no one-fits-all approach to enhancing institutional and policy coherence, the authors identified six good practices based on the German case study, offering valuable insights into what enables post-2015 agenda coherence.